 |
| Microsoft Wireless Display Adapter |
See Wireless HDTV Video (original)
The ability to beam video to a HDTV screen without
wires has been promised for quite some time, but the product methods on
offer (
DLNA,
Miracast,
Wi-Fi Direct) have proved to be disappointing, complex and/or problematic. This update adds an additional option.
Microsoft Wireless Display Adapter
Promising easy setup and compatibility with both Android (4.2.1 and later) and Windows (8.1 and later),
Microsoft Wireless Display Adapter comes close to hitting the mark. Setup is indeed easy (though not entirely free of problems, since more than one connect attempt may be needed), and
audio sync and video quality are quite good (significantly better than Chromecast), but
motion tends to be a bit jerky (1080p video tested over a short distance from Windows 8.1 with Intel i7 processor, Intel HD Graphics 5500, and Intel 802.11ac adapter), clearly
not as good as HDMI cable connection. (Frames are probably being dropped to maintain streaming.)
 |
| Google Chromecast |
Google Chromecast
With mighty Google behind it, inexpensive
Chromecast
would seem a sure winner. But right out of the box it can be
problematic because it insists on network capabilities (access to Google
Public DNS servers) that make it incompatible with some wireless
routers. (See
Chromecast Router Compatibility)
Past that point things can look good at first blush, as when casting
the screen of an Android mobile, or streaming YouTube video. But push it
a bit harder and warts appear. Local video (from Android mobile or
Chrome browser) is limited to 720p and relatively low bit rate by
default, with poor quality, and even when
pushed to its limits,
quality is still only mediocre at best. So if you care about video
quality, Chromecast is really just another Internet streaming option.
DLNA
Many "smart" HDTV sets claim DLNA Player support, which
should make it possible to beam video to them over a network connection
(wired or wireless), and the ubiquitous
Windows Media Player includes DLNA Server support. (See
Media Streaming with Windows 7)
But try to make it work and you're very likely to run into
compatibility problems, since many HDTV sets are very fussy about what
video formats they will (and will not) play, and Windows Media Player
does not support
transcoding
between formats. (While there DLNA servers that can transcode on the
fly, they can be difficult to set up, and the resulting quality is often
mediocre. Your best bet is to use
Handbrake to transcode to MPEG-4 in advance.) But even when it works, video quality is noticeably inferior to a wired
HDMI connection.
Bottom line: Beaming of HDTV video without wires remains a work in progress.
- For best quality use a wired HDMI connection.
- If you must have wireless, Microsoft Wireless Display Adapter is the best bet.